ControlAV

Home

Overview

Equipment

Story so far

Help me

Site History

DVDs in 1080i, from a network share: Nirvana

Jan 1, 2005

Roku have posted a beta of their 2.0 software for the Roku HD1000, and it has improved greatly in the video playback area.

For me the key new feature is the ability to play DVD .VOB files directly from a file share, and output 1080i (or 720p) via component cables. There are a few DVD players that can emit HD resolutions, though they are always encrypted, and my TV (Dell W3000) has no HDCP inputs. There are a few devices that can play DVD files from a net share. I believe the Roku is the first device that can do both (though others have since pointed me to this which appears to prove me wrong).

Right now you have to rename the .VOB files to .MPG, but that will be fixed according to the Forum. I went through a couple of the 200gigs worth of DVDs I have ripped on my file server (with DVDDecrypter) and did the rename to check them out. Finding Nemo looked amazing, and that should keep my daughter happy (the actual DVD has started skipping due to overuse).

This means you can kind of save $25000 over the Kaleidescape system, a hugely overpriced system for playing DVDs over your network. Now that is a serious saving!

I compared a ripped Terminator Special Edition DVD to the same movie broadcast on HDNet Movies. On my hardware, the Roku-played DVD looked better (at 720p in both cases, the preferred resolution for my TV). Caveats: YMMV, this is on a pretty small TV (30"), its the only movie I could find that I owned and was available on satellite in HD, it could have been a bad transfer etc.

Looks like the Roku will keep me happy until the real HD DVD issues have been resolved, and I can buy actual product.

As it is a beta there are some issues, the main one being the lack of FF/RW. Right now those buttons go to the next/prev VOB file, so you cant navigate DVD tracks, or skip ads (if you play TS files from your HTPC). Also the sound sometimes quits when skipping tracks, but comes back when you skip again. The good news is that all the video files that the 1.x software choked on play perfectly with 2.0.

I dont think they will be adding DVD menu navigation etc support, at least for 2.0, but I can live without that. Looks like there are few improvements for audio playback, with 2.0 (wisely) concentrating on video improvements.

Top

ControlAV is a trademark of Andy Pennell.